The love affair of Americans with toasts continue to heat up. More than 70 percent of Americans begin their day with a toast and pair it with eggs, bacon, jelly, or any other ingredient. With artisanal breads getting whipped up every single day, families are turning to pop-up toasters to recreate their favorite breakfasts. Unfortunately, the conventional 2-slice toaster is often not enough for a family of four. You will need an appliance that can deliver 4 toasts at a time.

A 4-slice toaster is perfect for large families. However, it is also ideal for single households that cannot live without a pile of nicely-done toasts on the breakfast table every single day. This article is for those who want a dependable 4-slice toaster. We came up with a list of the 10 best 4 slice toasters on the market you can choose from and bring home to your family. is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

 I. Our Top 5 Picks for 4 Slice Toasters 

II. What to Look for When Buying a 4 Slice Toaster


Picking the right 4-slice toaster for your kitchen or office kitchen requires a basic understanding of the features you need to make awesome slices of toast. Here are several of the most important things you need to look for when shopping for a 4-slice toaster.

Browning Settings

One of the absolute musts that a 4-slice toaster should have is a mechanism that allows you to control the level of brownness or shading of your toast. Some of us prefer our toast to have that classic light brown color with a slight crisp on the surface. There are also those who prefer their toasts to have a darker shade. A good 4-slice toaster should have enough shade or browning settings to help you get your desired shade of toast.

Toaster Slot Width

It would be best to get a toaster with variable width toaster slots. This feature is important if you are like some people who like to experiment with their toasts. You can put in any slice of bread of different thickness. This is better than having a fixed width slot.

High Lift

One of the most often overlooked feature of a good pop-up toaster is the height lift mechanism once the bread is toasted. The higher the lift, the easier it will be for you to remove the toast from the slots. This helps you avoid burning yourself. There is also no need to stick a fork or a small knife into the slot just to remove the toast.

Ease of Use 

Look at the control interface of the toaster. Some brands will feature the classic dial type of controls, while other products will come with a touch button interface. Choose one that will be a lot easier for you to operate.

Ease of Cleaning and Maintenance

One of the most tedious aspects of owning a pop-up toaster is cleaning. There will always be toasted bread crumbs at the bottom of the toasting chamber. A device with a removable crumb tray should help address the need for effortless cleaning. Another feature that can help take the hassle of cleaning and maintenance off your shoulders is a nonstick interior surface. It is not an absolute must, but it sure can help.


There are brands that are well-known for making high-quality 4-slice toasters. These products can last up to several years. If you observe the proper care, operation, and maintenance of these electrical appliances, there is a good chance that you can also use them for more than a decade. A good indicator of the durability of a toaster is the number of years the manufacturer will back the quality of its product. The longer the assurance is, the greater is the likelihood that the 4-slice toaster is durable.

Other Features

Check out the other toaster features that may interest you. You can look for self-adjusting guides, defrost and reheat settings, and other toasting functions. You might also want a toaster with a digital display or with different accessories. Choose those features that matter to you.

III. The 10 Best 4 Slice Toasters

1. Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster


There are many reasons why the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 has earned the nod of thousands of consumers. This toaster has a classic design that can transport you to the 60s era where everything looks Marilyn Monroe-sexy.

It is wrong to think that the functions of this toaster are also that of the bygone era. This toaster comes with 6 levels of browning to give you exceptional control of the shade of your toast. The slots are also wide enough to accommodate a 1.5-inch thick slice. This baby comes with a bagel function to accompany reheat and defrost features, too.

One minor flaw is the location of the cord storage. Most appliances will have the cord wound at the side. The CPT-180P1 stores its cord under the toaster. The good news is that there will be no unsightly cords sticking out of the appliance.

Overall, the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 is an exceptional 4-slice toaster. It is easy to operate and maintain. The toaster also gives you optimum control over your toast. That is why we consider this the best.


  • 6 browning settings
  • 3 additional functions
  • Wide toaster slots
  • Elegant, retro design
  • Easy to operate and clean


  • Cord storage under the toaster

2. Hamilton Beach 24633 4-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster


The Hamilton Beach 24633 4-Slice Toaster has a contemporary design that blends a brushed stainless-steel front panel with mahogany-like body. The dials, control buttons, and the top face plate will sit right at home in the company of silver and stainless-steel kitchen items.

The 24633 can brown your bread up to 6 different shades with a simple twist of a knob. You can place a thick bagel in the 4 slots and never worry about picking them up once done. Its high lift mechanism ensures your toasts pop out easily.

Unfortunately, this toaster does not have a reheat function. It does have a mode for toasting bagels and defrosting food. You may also be put off by the fact that the toaster is composed mainly of plastic. The good news is that the materials do not look cheap and are very sturdy.

The Hamilton Beach 24633 remains a great 4-slice toaster for those who want a no-nonsense appliance. It is easy to operate, clean, and maintain and looks elegant on any kitchen countertop, too.


  • 6 shade settings
  • Wide slots
  • High-lift boost
  • With auto shutoff feature
  • Contemporary design


  • No reheat function
  • Mostly made of plastic

3. KitchenAid RKMT4203CA 4-Slice Pro Line Toaster


If you want to put “WOW!” in your kitchen, then pick the KitchenAid RKMT4203CA. This is a fully-automated 4-slice toaster that simplifies the way you toast your bread. Also, it has a timeless design that transcends eras of toaster ingenuity.

At the core of the RKMT4203CA is a toasting technology that allows it to brown bread up to 8 different shades. It can defrost your food, toast your bagel, and keep your toast warm, too. This is a very useful feature for people who may not be ready to spread some butter or jelly on their toast the moment it pops out. Even the toast lifter is a joy to operate. This baby features aluminum and chrome construction that you can expect to give it the durability you need in a toaster.

Keep in mind that all these features will translate to a higher price. Also, the RKMT4203CA has a larger footprint than other 4-slice toasters we have seen.

We recommend the KitchenAid RKMT4203CA if you are looking for a statement 4-slice toaster in your kitchen.


  • 8 levels of browning
  • Fully automated controls
  • Ingenious notifications
  • Super-elegant and classic look
  • Durable construction


  • Expensive
  • Large footprint

4. Toaster 4 Slice CUSINAID 4 Wide Slots Stainless Steel Toasters


The CUSINAID Toaster can deliver toasts after perfect toasts done to your exacting demands. This small kitchen appliance allows you to dial up to 7 different shades on your bread. You can put an ordinary slice of white bread or even a bagel and it will always turn up nicely.

CUSINAID retained the classic look of the 1960s toaster and gave it a few touches of contemporary toasting technology. The stainless-steel housing with light-blue trim should sit nicely in any kitchen. The slots are wide and the control knobs are very easy to twist. The company decided to ditch the label for each control button. Instead, CUSINAID uses symbols to mark its different functions.

We were surprised to learn that the CUSINAID does not have a bagel function. Its cord storage is also under the toaster. On the bright side, these are very minor issues. We believe the CUSINAID is a good 4-slice toaster to have in your kitchen. It is classy and can deliver nice toasts every time.


  • 7 shades of toast
  • Can defrost and reheat food
  • Can toast 1.5-inch thick breads
  • Easy to clean
  • Sturdy construction


  • Cord storage under the toaster
  • No bagel functions

5. Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Smart Toaster


Having the Breville BTA840XL on your kitchen countertop is like living in a futuristic world. The form factor is that of a classic toaster. The performance and functionality are something else. This toaster delivers good ‘ol toasted bread using highly advanced technologies that very few other brands have the courage to integrate into their products.

The touch controls line up at the front edge of the top of the toaster. Here, you get to access different modes. You can defrost your food and even toast a large bagel. Dual sliders at the lower portion of the front of the toaster lets you pick the level of browning of your toast. There is a row of LED lights that also display the level of browning. You can also peek of your toast to check its browning.

While the Breville BTA840XL is a bit expensive, it remains an excellent choice for those who want a more modern-looking appliance with a set of futuristic functions. This baby can last a full decade, too, if you know how to care for it.


  • 5 browning settings
  • Fully automated controls
  • Convenient operation
  • Comes with a “lift & look” feature
  • Modern, elegant design


  • A bit expensive

6. Oster 4-Slice Toaster Brushed Metal


Oster is one of those brands that you can expect to deliver good quality products at an affordable price. This is what you get with the TSSTTRWF4S-SHP 4-Slice Toaster. This small kitchen appliance can produce nicely-toasted breads fast and with the kind of browning you would expect from a high-quality toaster.

The Oster 4-slice toaster has the classic 20th century design to complement 4 different modes you would expect from a 21st century toaster. Reheating and defrosting your food are easy. Dialing the shades of brown on your toast is also effortless. Cleanups are never an issue and its retractable power cord makes storing this toaster a breeze.

Our only issue about this Oster toaster is that its lift height is a bit short for certain breads. Make sure you put only at least regular-sized breads, unless you do not mind prying them out of their slots.

The Oster TSSTTRWF4S-SHP has all the makings of a reliable toaster. Its stainless-steel construction gives it durability that will see you using this toaster for many years to come.


  • 7 shades of toast
  • With 4 different modes
  • Extra-wide slots
  • Easy to clean
  • Affordable


  • Lift height a bit short

7. Dualit 4 Slice NewGen Toaster Copper


There is something about British-made products that make them so likeable. Take the Dualit 4 Slice NewGen Toaster, for instance. The design is unique in that it follows the shape of a classic loaf of bread. However, the true mark of British ingenuity is in the NewGen’s toasting technology.

This Dualit toaster allows you to heat up only the slot that you are going to use in toasting your bread. Most of the toasters we have on the market heat up all 4 slots, even though you only need 1 or 2 slots. Inside each slot is Dualit’s ProHeat technology that toasts your breads to perfection.

Getting perfect toasts can be quite tricky at first. You see, there are no absolute browning values on the dial of the NewGen. You will have to test it by intuition. This is a toaster that is best for bread masters.

It is important to understand that Dualit designed the NewGen 4-Slice Toaster for commercial use. It does not mean you cannot use this in your home if you want perfect toasts.


  • Selectable slots
  • Wide toasting slots
  • Efficient ProHeat element
  • Mechanical operation
  • Very unusual yet elegant design


  • Browning settings can be tricky to master

8. BLACK+DECKER TR4310FBD 4-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster


We know that BLACK+DECKER products are mighty expensive. You would be surprised that the TR4310FBD is more affordable than other 4-slice toasters on the market. And with the BLACK+DECKER badge emblazoned on its front panel; you know that this toaster is going to keep on serving you excellent toasts for many years.

We admire the styling of the TR4310FBD. It has that stunning silver-and-black ombre effect that should give your kitchen a nice aesthetic upgrade. Browning your toasts is also easy as turning a dial. You can defrost, toast a bagel, and reheat, too. The side crumb tray is a breeze to clean.

One issue about the TR4310FBD 4-slice toaster is that it is a bit lightweight. It tends to tip forward when you press on the toast ejector levers. This surprised us because we expected the toaster to be stable on the countertop, given its size.

For its awesome ombre look, unquestionable durability, and dependable performance, the BLACK+DECKER TR4310FBD is a wonderful 4-slice toaster. It will never hurt your pocket. It can also give your kitchen a more sophisticated and futuristic touch.


  • 7 shades of toast
  • Wide slots
  • 3 additional functions
  • Very stylish design
  • Affordable


  • Tends to tip forward when ejecting the toast

9. KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster with Brushed


People who love shiny things will love the KRUPS KH7340 Breakfast Set 4-slice Toaster. This small kitchen appliance has an elegant chrome finish that covers its durable stainless-steel construction. The design has a more contemporary look than most toasters.

Fitting a thick slice of bread is easy as the KRUPS toaster comes with 4 large slots. You can also brown your bread up to 6 different shades. It is also easy to defrost and reheat food items. And when it comes to giving your bagel a nice hue, the KRUPS toaster can do that, too.

One of the most unsettling things about the KH734D toaster is its strong burnt smell the first time that you use it. That is why KRUPS recommends priming your toaster in a room with adequate ventilation. Once primed, toasting breads and other foods should be a pleasant activity in the kitchen.

The KRUPS KH734D is perfect for those who have stainless steel appliances and décor in their kitchen. It does a good job of browning breads just the way you like them.


  • 6 browning levels
  • Wide slots
  • 3 additional functions
  • Sleek and fancy design
  • Durable construction


  • Nasty burnt smell during first operation

10. Cuisinart CPT-142P1 4-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster


Budget-conscious folks also must consider the quality of the products that they purchase. And when it comes to a good-quality and budget-friendly 4-slice toaster, the Cuisinart CPT-142P1 is an obvious choice. This is an appliance that can make toasting breads so much more fun without costing you that much.

The CPT-142P1 is a lightweight toaster that can outperform other heavyweights on the market. Its all-white body with stainless steel accents makes this Cuisinart toaster suitable in many modern kitchens. Its ability to toast bread is also as remarkable as defrosting and reheating capabilities. You can brown your bagel, too. It has a footprint that is perfect for households with small countertops.

As a budget-friendly toaster, you can expect a catch with the CPT-142P1. This would be its mostly plastic construction. The good news is that it does not show because of the way Cuisinart designed the toaster.

The Cuisinart CPT-142P1 is an exciting toaster that can deliver 4 amazing toasts every time. It is compact and has a price tag that is friendlier than most 4-slice toasters.


  • 7 shades of toast
  • Comes with 3 different functions
  • Very easy to maintain
  • Easy to operate
  • Very affordable


  • Mostly plastic

IV. Conclusion

A good 4-slice toaster allows you to control the level of browning of your toasts. The slots are wide enough to accommodate thick breads. It is also wise to pick a toaster with added functions, such as a defroster and a reheater. If it can keep your toast warm until you decide to chow on your bread, then that toaster will be great, too. The best 4 slice toasters are durable, without hurting your budget. These are the qualities we found in the Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster. You can check it out for yourself or try the other products we featured in this article.

The 10 Best 4 Slice Toasters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *